On Wednesday, the UN announced that it would not participate in relief efforts in the Marjeh area because of US “militarization of humanitarian aid”.
You are invited to vote in the Poll, “Is President Obama more of the same?” appearing on the left sidebar.
|By: Jim White Friday February 19, 2010|
UN Logo from Wikimedia Commons
George W. Bush made no secret of his disregard for the United Nations, railing that “we really don’t need anybody’s permission” just prior to the invasion of Iraq. Bush followed that statement by ordering UN weapons inspectors out of Iraq a few days before the invasion, despite the fact that the head of the effort, Mohamed ElBaradei, would subsequently win a Nobel Peace Prize for the work Bush so unceremoniously ended. In his State of the Union speech in 2004, months after the invasion, Bush doubled down on the permission remark and seemed to specifically rebuke the Security Council when he said “America will never seek a permission slip to defend the security of our country”.
In addition, Bush continually advocated for reducing US funding of the United Nations and, in a move characterized by David Corn of The Nation as giving the UN “the finger”, Bush nominated UN-hater John Bolton as Ambassador to the UN. As Corn pointed out, Bolton was known for his statement that “If the UN Secretariat building in New York lost ten stories, it wouldn’t make a bit of difference.”
Despite the fact that Barack Obama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for not being George W. Bush, Obama is continuing to disregard the UN on many fronts. Consider the following examples:
– Last October, the UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial Executions stated that US reliance on missiles fired remotely from drones “may well violate international humanitarian law“. Rather than simply ignoring the warning, Obama instead appears to have gone a step further and now even has US citizens on his list for extrajudicial executions.
– When the UN’s Goldstone Report found evidence of both Hamas and Israel committing war crimes, Goldstone openly invited the Obama administration to detail its objections to the report. Instead, Obama did nothing while the US House voted 344 to 36 to reject the report as biased against Israel.
– Despite a report from the UN that the US still maintains secret prisons in Afghanistan and a very dubious denial of them by the US head of detentions in Afghanistan, Obama has put into place a Bush-era denier of prisoners’ rights to head all US policy for prisoners.
– On Wednesday, the UN announced that it would not participate in relief efforts in the Marjeh area because of US “militarization of humanitarian aid”.
While not engaging in the openly hostile rhetoric of Bush, Obama has continued Bush’s policy of disregarding UN findings. Are these the actions of an administration pursuing a policy of peace?
The Preamble to the UN Charter seeks “to establish conditions under which justice and respect for the obligations arising from treaties and other sources of international law can be maintained” as a means to preventing “the scourge of war”. Obama would do well to read the entire Charter and reflect on the US role in the preamble’s goal “to practice tolerance and live together in peace with one another as good
Civilian Deaths Mar Marjah Offensive
12 Civilians Killed in Rocket Attack; U.S. General Apologizes; 2 Coalition Servicemen Killed
The projectiles veered 300 yards (meters) off target and blasted a house in the Nad Ali district, which includes Marjah, NATO added.
CBS News correspondent Mandy Clark toured the area with the Marines’ commanding officer there, Brig. Gen. Larry Nicholson.
“They got a suspected IED site over there and they got a souk, a market, over there,” the general said. As he crossed the bridge his troops erected only yesterday, the Nicholson had one overriding concern – improvised explosive devices
“We expected a lot of IEDs but we’re finding even more than what we expected, so I think the amount of IEDs is surpassing even our expectation,” he said.
The Taliban has had plenty of time to place booby traps in the path of advancing coalition forces. So the Marines are advancing very carefully, Clark reports.
The owner of one property was ordered by the Taliban to clear out – an occurrence suspicious enough to cause the Marines to search every inch of the property for bombs.
Overhead, unmanned planes scanned the terrain for suspected traps. When one is located the drone fires a missile to safely set off the bomb.
The civilian deaths were a blow to NATO and Afghan efforts to win the support of residents in the Marjah area, a major goal of the biggest ground offensive of the eight-year war. Marjah, which had a population of 80,000 before the offensive, is a Taliban logistical centre and a base for their lucrative opium trade which finances the insurgency.
The rockets were fired by a High Mobility Artillery Rocket System, or HIMARS, at insurgents who attacked U.S. and Afghan forces, wounding one American and one Afghan, NATO said in a statement. Instead, the projectiles veered 300 yards (meters) off target and blasted a house in the Nad Ali district, which includes Marjah, NATO added.
The top NATO commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, apologized to President Hamid Karzai for “this tragic loss of life” and suspended use of the sophisticated HIMARS system pending “a thorough review of this incident,” NATO said.
Before the offensive began Saturday, Karzai pleaded for the Afghan and foreign commanders to be “seriously careful for the safety of civilians.”
Karzai’s spokesman Waheed Omar said the president “is very upset about what happened” and has been “very seriously conveying his message” of restraint “again and again.”
Allied officials have reported two coalition deaths so far – one American and one Briton, who were both killed Saturday. Afghan officials said at least 27 insurgents have been killed in the offensive.
Nicholson is satisfied that his men are making good progress, though they are still coming under sporadic fire
“This is going to be a long tough slog over here,” Nicholson told Clark. “We think it’s going to be probably 30 days more work here
“It seems these guys want to get a bit closer,” Lt. Carl Quist said as bullets whizzed overhead.
Brig. Gen. Larry Nicholson, a top Marine commander in the south, predicted it could take 30 days to clear Marjah because of all the hidden explosives.
Marines said they would have preferred a straight-up fight to what they called the “death at every corner” crawl they faced as they made their way through the town.
“Basically, if you hear the boom, it’s good. It means you’re still alive after the thing goes off,” said Lance Corp. Justin Hennes, 22, of Lakeland, Florida.
To bypass heavily mined bridges, Marine engineers erected their own Vietnam-era metal spans over canals that irrigate opium poppy fields.
As Marines pushed deeper into town, gunfire forced them to take cover in buildings and compounds not yet cleared of booby traps. In one compound, a dog trained to detect explosives discovered a massive bomb hidden in a pile of trash.
Some troops complained that the strict rules issued by McChrystal to spare civilians were making their job more difficult and dangerous. Under the rules, troops cannot fire at people unless they commit a hostile act or show hostile intent.
U.S. soldiers operating near Marjah said the Taliban can fire on them, then set aside their weapon and walk freely out of a compound, possibly toward a weapons cache in another location.
A few crafty, determined insurgents can keep a larger force engaged for hours with some degree of impunity.
“The inability to stop people who don’t have weapons is the main hindrance right now,” said 1st Lt. Gavin McMahon of Brooklyn, N.Y. McMahon. “They know how to use our ROE against us,” referring to the Rules of Engagement.
In areas where troops have wrested control from the Taliban, the second phase of the operation is under way – trying to convince civilians that their future lies with the government and not the insurgents.
Several shuras, or meetings with community leaders, have been held in Marjah and the surrounding Nad Ali district with more planned.
In one village, Qari Sahib, Afghan officials met with residents Sunday, promising to provide security, pave a road and build a school and a clinic. In exchange, they urged the villagers to renounce the Taliban and push militants to reintegrate into society. To show good faith, a resident who had been arrested for alleged militant activity was freed.
“This is all to the benefit for you people but we need your co-operation,” Deputy Gov. Abdul Sattar Mirzekwal, told more than 100 villagers gathered outside a mosque. “Do not let the Taliban come into your area and disrupt security.”
Most villagers at the shura expressed support for the government. Others expressed skepticism, laughing and paying little attention to the officials’ promises.
Abdul Wali, a 23-year-old farmer, said he hoped people would give the government a chance.
“I’m afraid that if they do not join with the government, there will be fights, clashes and gunbattles in our village,” he said. “I hope the government will fulfil all the promises it is making.”